Knowledge Representation for Health%2DCare Data

Supporting the Abstraction of Clinical Practice Guidelines Using Information Extraction.

Mapping the Users%27 Problem Solving Strategies in the Participatory Design of Visual Analytics Methods.

Easing semantically enriched information retrieval %2D An interactive semi%2Dautomatic annotation system for medical documents.

Proceedings of the ACM SIGKDD Workshop on Visual Analytics and Knowledge Discovery Integrating Automated Analysis with Interactive Exploration

Hierarchical Temporal Patterns and Interactive Aggregated Views for Pixel%2DBased Visualizations.

Bridging an Asbru Protocol to an Existing Electronic Patient Record.

Modelling Clinical Guidelines and Protocols for the Prevention of Risks Against Patient Safety.

Embedding Oncologic Protocols into the Provision of Care The Oncocure Project.

Versioning computer%2Dinterpretable guidelines Semi%2Dautomatic modeling of %27Living Guidelines%27 using an information extraction method.

To Score or Not to Score%3F Tripling Insights for Participatory Design.

Easing the Formalization of Clinical Guidelines with a User%2Dtailored

Visual Analytical Methods to Identify Family Clustered Diseases.



Comparing Information Visualization Tools Focusing on the Temporal Dimensions.


Modeling Clinical Protocols Using Semantic MediaWiki The Case of the Oncocure Project.


Visualizations at First Sight Do Insights Require Training%3F.

Formalizing %27Living Guidelines%27 Using LASSIE A Multi%2Dstep Information Extraction Method.
Abstract. Living guidelines are documents presenting up-to-date and state-ofthe-art knowledge to practitioners. To have guidelines implemented by computersupport they firstly have to be formalized in a computer-interpretable form. Due to the complexity of such formats the formalization process is challenging, but burdensome and time-consuming. The LASSIE methodology supports this task by formalizing guidelines in several steps from the textual form to the guideline representation language Asbru using a document-centric approach. LASSIE uses Information Extraction technique to semi-automatically accomplish these steps. We apply LASSIE to support the implementation of living guidelines. Based on a living guideline published by the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) we show that adaptations of previously formalized guidelines can be accomplished easily and fast. By using this new approach only new and changed text parts have to be modeled. Furthermore, models can be inherited from previously modeled guideline versions that were added by domain experts. 1
Visual Methods for Analyzing Time%2DOriented Data.
 Providing appropriate methods to facilitate the analysis of time-oriented data is a key issue in many application domains. In this paper, we focus on the unique role of the parameter time in the context of visually driven data analysis. We will discuss three major aspects – visualization, analysis, and the user. It will be illustrated that it is necessary to consider the characteristics of time when generating visual representations. For that purpose we take a look at different types of time and present visual examples. Integrating visual and analytical methods has become an increasingly important issue. Therefore, we present our experiences in temporal data abstraction, principal component analysis, and clustering of larger volumes of time-oriented data. The third main aspect we discuss is supporting user-centered visual analysis. We describe event-based visualization as a promising means to adapt the visualization pipeline to needs and tasks of users.
Formalizing %27Living Guidelines%27 Using LASSIE A Multi%2Dstep Information Extraction Method.
Abstract. Living guidelines are documents presenting up-to-date and state-ofthe-art knowledge to practitioners. To have guidelines implemented by computersupport they firstly have to be formalized in a computer-interpretable form. Due to the complexity of such formats the formalization process is challenging, but burdensome and time-consuming. The LASSIE methodology supports this task by formalizing guidelines in several steps from the textual form to the guideline representation language Asbru using a document-centric approach. LASSIE uses Information Extraction technique to semi-automatically accomplish these steps. We apply LASSIE to support the implementation of living guidelines. Based on a living guideline published by the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) we show that adaptations of previously formalized guidelines can be accomplished easily and fast. By using this new approach only new and changed text parts have to be modeled. Furthermore, models can be inherited from previously modeled guideline versions that were added by domain experts. 1
Maintaining Formal Models of Living Guidelines Efficiently.
Abstract. Translating clinical guidelines into formal models is beneficial in many ways, but expensive. The progress in medical knowledge requires clinical guidelines to be updated at relatively short intervals, leading to the term living guideline. This causes potentially expensive, frequent updates of the corresponding formal models. When performing these updates, there are two goals: The modelling effort must be minimised and the links between the original document and the formal model must be maintained. In this paper, we describe our solution, using tools and techniques developed during the Protocure II project 1. 1
Embedding the Evidence Information in Guideline Representation Languages.
Computer-Supported Guidelines into the Decision-Making Process Conducted for the purpose of receiving the academic title ’Doktorin der technischen Wissenschaften’
Mixing Evaluation Methods for Assessing the Utility of an Interactive InfoVis Technique.
Abstract. We describe the results of an empirical study comparing an interactive Information Visualization (InfoVis) technique called Gravi++ (GRAVI), Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA) and Machine Learning (ML). The application domain is the psychotherapeutic treatment of anorectic young women. The three techniques are supposed to support the therapists in finding the variables which influence success or failure in therapy. To evaluate the utility of the three techniques we developed on the one hand a report system which helped subjects to formulate and document in a self-directed manner the insights they gained when using the three techniques. On the other hand, focus groups were held with the subjects. The combination of these very different evaluation methods prevents jumping to false conclusions and enables for an comprehensive assessment of the tested techniques. The combined results indicate that the three techniques (EDA, ML, and GRAVI) are complementary and therefore should be used in conjunction.
Social Rewarding in Wiki Systems %2D Motivating the Community.

Social Rewarding in Wiki Systems %2D Motivating the Community.



Evaluating an InfoVis Technique Using Insight Reports.
The evaluation of Information Visualization (InfoVis) techniques can help to identify specific strengths and weaknesses of these methods. The following article describes the results of an empirical study assessing the contribution of an interactive InfoVis method based on a spring metaphor (GRAVI), Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA) and Machine Learning (ML) to ease understanding. The application domain is the psychotherapeutic treatment of anorectic young women. The three methods are supposed to support the therapists in finding the variables which influence success or failure of the therapy. To conduct the evaluation we developed a report system which helped subjects to formulate and document in a self-directed manner the insights they gained when using the three methods. The results indicate that the three methods are complementary and should be used in conjunction.
A Meta Schema for Evidence Information in Clinical Practice Guidelines as a Basis for Decision%2DMaking.
Clinical practice guidelines are an important instrument to aid physicians during medical diagnosis and treatment. Currently, different guideline developing organizations try to define and integrate evidence information into such guidelines. However, the coding schemas and taxonomies used for the evidence information differ widely, which makes the use cumbersome and demanding. We explored these various schemas and developed a meta schema for the evidence information, which covers the most important components of the existing ones, is comprehensible, and easy to understand for the users. We developed and assessed the usefulness and applicability of our meta schema with guideline developers and physicians. Keywords: Clinical practice guidelines, evidence-based medicine, recommendations, study characteristics, clinical decision support, otolaryngology
Tutorial Introduction to Visual Analytics.

Towards a conceptual framework for visual analytics of time and time%2Doriented data.

Towards a conceptual framework for visual analytics of time and time%2Doriented data.

Modeling Treatment Processes Using Information Extraction.
Abstract. Living guidelines are documents presenting up-to-date and state-ofthe-art knowledge to practitioners. To have guidelines implemented by computersupport they firstly have to be formalized in a computer-interpretable form. Due to the complexity of such formats the formalization process is challenging, but burdensome and time-consuming. The LASSIE methodology supports this task by formalizing guidelines in several steps from the textual form to the guideline representation language Asbru using a document-centric approach. LASSIE uses Information Extraction technique to semi-automatically accomplish these steps. We apply LASSIE to support the implementation of living guidelines. Based on a living guideline published by the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) we show that adaptations of previously formalized guidelines can be accomplished easily and fast. By using this new approach only new and changed text parts have to be modeled. Furthermore, models can be inherited from previously modeled guideline versions that were added by domain experts. 1
How can information extraction ease formalizing treatment processes in clinical practice guidelines%3F A method and its evaluation.

Artificial Intelligence in Medicine AIME %2705.
Extraction and use of linguistic patterns for modelling medical guidelines §
Visualizing time%2Doriented data %2D A systematic view.
The analysis of time-oriented data is an important task in many application scenarios. In recent years, a variety of techniques for visualizing such data have been published. This variety makes it difficult for prospective users to select methods or tools that are useful for their particular task at hand. In this article, we develop and discuss a systematic view on the diversity of methods for visualizing time-oriented data. With the proposed categorization we try to untangle the visualization of time-oriented data, which is such an important concern in Visual Analytics. The categorization is not only helpful for users, but also for researchers to identify future tasks in Visual Analytics.
Visualizing time%2Doriented data %2D A systematic view.
The analysis of time-oriented data is an important task in many application scenarios. In recent years, a variety of techniques for visualizing such data have been published. This variety makes it difficult for prospective users to select methods or tools that are useful for their particular task at hand. In this article, we develop and discuss a systematic view on the diversity of methods for visualizing time-oriented data. With the proposed categorization we try to untangle the visualization of time-oriented data, which is such an important concern in Visual Analytics. The categorization is not only helpful for users, but also for researchers to identify future tasks in Visual Analytics.
Bridging the Gap Between Informal and Formal Guideline Representations.
Abstract. Clinical guidelines are important means to improve quality of health care while limiting cost and supporting the medical staff. They are written as free text with tables and figures. Transforming them into a formal, computer-processable representation is a difficult task requiring both computer scientist skills and medical knowledge. To bridge this gap, we designed an intermediate representation (or ontology) which serves as a mediator between the original text and different formal guideline representations. It is easier to use than the latter, structures the original prose and helps to spot missing information and contradictions. In this paper we describe the representation and a practical evaluation thereof through the modelling of a real-world clinical guideline. 1
Environment%2DDriven Skeletal Plan Execution for the Medical Domain.
Abstract. An important application of both data abstraction and plan execution is the execution of clinical guidelines and protocols (CGP), both to validate them against a large set of test cases and to provide decision support at the point of care. CGPs can be represented and executed as a hierarchy of skeletal plans. To bridge the gap between low-level data and high-level concepts in the CGP, intelligent temporal data abstraction must be integrated with plan execution. In this paper we describe a solution to this challenge which was implemented as part of the European project Protocure II to improve the quality of CGPs. They are translated to the high-level plan representation language Asbru which again is compiled into a network of abstraction modules by the system. Then this network performs the content of the plans triggered by the arriving patient data. By this, we seamlessly integrate the synchronisation of guideline execution with observed patient state, complex temporal abstractions and execution of complex plans without requiring the user to handle the low-level details. Instead, user-friendly tools are used to create and maintain the guideline. 1
Interactive%2C Task%2DOriented Visualizations to Explore Decay Chain Calculation.

Improving medical protocols by formal methods.
Objectives During the last decade, evidence-based medicine has given rise to an increasing number of medical practice guidelines and protocols. However, the work done on developing and distributing protocols outweighs the efforts on guar-anteeing their quality. Indeed, anomalies like ambiguity and incompleteness are frequent in medical protocols. Recent efforts have tried to address the problem of protocol improvement, but they are not sufficient since they rely on informal pro-cesses and notations. Our objective is to improve the quality of medical protocols. ∗ This work has been done in the framework of the EU project Protocure (IST-2001-33049 – Protocure, Improving medical protocols by formal methods).
CareVis Integrated visualization of computerized protocols and temporal patient data.
Objective: Currently, visualization support for patient data analysis is mostly limited to the representation of directly measured data. Contextual information on performed treatment steps is an important source to find reasons and explanations for certain phenomena in the measured patient data, but is mostly spared out in the analysis process. This work aims to fill this gap via integrating classical data visualization and visualization of treatment information. Methods and Material: We considered temporal as well as logical data aspects and applied a user-centered development approach that was guided by user input gathered via a user study, design reviews, and prototype evaluations. Furthermore, we investigated the novel PlanningLine glyph, that is used to represent plans in the temporal domain, via a comparative empirical user study. Results: Our interactive visualization approach CareVis provides multiple simultaneous views to cover different aspects of the complex underlying data structure of treatment plans and patient data. The tightly coupled views use visualization methods well-known to domain experts and are designed to facilitate users ’ tasks. The views are based on the concepts of clinical algorithm maps and LifeLines which have been extended in order to cope with the powerful and expressive plan representation language Asbru. Initial feedback of physicians was encouraging and is accompanied by empirical evidence which verifies that PlanningLines are well suited to manage temporal uncertainty. Conclusion: The interactive integration of different visualization methods forms a novel way of combining, relating, and analyzing different kinds of medical data and information that otherwise would be separated.
Artificial Intelligence in Medicine

Improving Clinical Guideline Implementation Through Prototypical Design Patterns.

MHB %2D A Many%2DHeaded Bridge Between Informal and Formal Guideline Representations.

Gaining Process Information from Clinical Practice Guidelines Using Information Extraction.

pdf2table A Method to Extract Table Information from PDF Files.
Abstract. Tables are a common structuring element in many documents, such as PDF files. To reuse such tables, appropriate methods need to be develop, which capture the structure and the content information. We have developed several heuristics which together recognize and decompose tables in PDF files and store the extracted data in a structured data format (XML) for easier reuse. Additionally, we implemented a prototype, which gives the user the ability of making adjustments on the extracted data. Our work shows that purely heuristic-based approaches can achieve good results, especially for lucid tables. 1
An empirical investigation on the visualization of temporal uncertainties in software engineering project planning.

Exploring Highly Structured Data A Comparative Study of Stardinates and Parallel Coordinates.
Comparing different Information Visualization (InfoVis) techniques is a challenging task and a necessary step to reach the users and their tasks. We evaluated the effectiveness in visualizing psychotherapeutic data of two InfoVis techniques, namely the Stardinates and the Parallel Coordinates by a comparative study with 22 participants. Based on three research questions we interpret the results of our study in order to derive statements on both visualization techniques. We evaluated (1) the time participants were engaged in testing our material, (2) the number of correct answers, (3) subjects ’ statements, which were categorized by the type of statement, and (4) the subjects ’ key statements in comparison to those defined by an expert. Our empirical results indicate that the Stardinates are a more appropriate method for interpreting such highly structured data in detail whereas Parallel Coordinates show advantages for gaining information at the first glance. 1
PlanningLines Novel Glyphs for Representing Temporal Uncertainties and Their Evaluation.
Dealing with temporal uncertainties is a key issue in domains like project management or medical treatment planning. However, support for temporal indeterminacies is not very well integrated in current methods, techniques, and tools. In this paper we present a visualization technique called PlanningLines that allows for representing temporal uncertainties and aims at supporting project managers in their difficult planning and controlling tasks. We conducted a controlled experiment to gather empirical evidence on the strengths and limitations of our approach. Main results are that PlanningLine users make fewer mistakes and are faster in conducting tasks than users of a traditional visualization technique.
Assessing the Usability of an Interactive Information Visualization Method as the First Step of a Sustainable Evaluation.
Gravi++ is a visualization method that is designed to support psychotherapists in their work with anorectic girls. During the therapy complex and time dependent data have to be analyzed. Statistical methods cannot be used in this context, and visualizations seem to be a viable alternative. Gravi++ is based on a spring metaphor. It can represent time dependent data easily. There is still too little systematic and empirically validated knowledge to support the design of such information visualizations. Therefore, extensive evaluation is necessary. The evaluation process is composed of two steps – a usability study and the evaluation of the Gravi++ method as such. The following paper describes the usability study. Methods used were usability inspection / guideline review, heuristic evaluation and focus groups. Heuristic evaluation was a very valuable method for identifying usability problems. Focus groups did not yield very much additional factual knowledge but gave important insights about the subjective importance of usability problems.
Gravi   Interactive Information Visualization to Explore Highly Structured Temporal Data.

Connecting time%2Doriented data and information to a coherent interactive visualization.
In modern intensive care units (ICUs), the medical staff has to monitor a huge amount of high-dimensional and timeoriented data, which needs to be visualized user- and taskspecifically to ease diagnosis and treatment planning. Available visual representations, like diagrams or charts neglect the implicit information as well as a-priory or associated knowledge about the data and its meaning (for example, 38.5C (101.3F) is moderate fever and 41C (105.8F) is critical fever). Another challenge is to provide appropriate interaction techniques to explore and navigate the data and its temporal dimensions. In this context one major challenge is to connect time-oriented data and information to a coherent interactive visualization. In this paper we present different interactive visualization techniques which enable the users to reveal the data at several levels of detail and abstraction, ranging from a broad overview to the fine structure. We will also introduce a time visualization and navigation technique that connects overview+detail, pan+zoom, and focus+context features to one powerful time-browser.
Temporal Plan Interdependencies.

Linking Clinical Guidelines with Formal Representations.
Abstract. Clinical guidelines have been used in the medical domain for some time now, primarily to reduce proneness to errors during the treatment of specific diseases. Recently, physicians have special software at their disposal, which supports them at decision-making based on computerized protocols and guidelines. Using such tools, physicians sometimes want to know the reason why the computer recommends a particular treatment method. To comprehend the suggestions, a connection between the original guideline and its computerized representation is needed. This paper introduces a tool that was designed to provide a solution for that, the so-called Guideline Markup Tool (GMT). This tool enables the protocol designer to create links between the original guideline and its formal representation. 1
The Stardinates %2D Visualizing Highly Structured Data.

Applying Information Visualization Techniques to Capture and Explore the Course of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy.
Tracking and especially comparing psychotherapeutic processes is a complex task involving a large number of individual and complexly related parameters. Therefore, descriptive and classical statistical methods are only suited for partial analyses. To overcome these limitations we introduce LinkVis, a new Information Visualization (InfoVis) tool used to visualize and evaluate psychotherapeutic processes. LinkVis is developed and clinically tested on the basis of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy treating anorectic girls. The user gets new insight into the data under investigation due to the combination of three di#erent visualization techniques: scatterplots, Cherno# faces, and parallel coordinates. LinkVis supports exploring of complex timedependent data in order to gain more information about the psychotherapeutic process, especially when comparing di#erent patients and groups.
ViCo A Metric for the Complexity of Information Visualizations.
Information Visualization produces a visual representation of  abstract data in order to facilitate a deeper level of understanding of the data  under investigation. This paper introduces ViCo, a metric for assessing  Information Visualization complexity. The proposed metric allows for the  measurement of Information Visualization complexity with respect to tasks and  users. The algorithm for developing such a metric for any chosen collection of  visualizations is described in general and then applied to two examples for  purposes of illustration.
Benefits of a Knowledge%2Dbased System for Parenteral Nutrition Support a Report after 5 Years of Routine Daily Use.
Calculating the daily changing composition of parenteral nutrition for small newborn infants is troublesome and time consuming routine work in neonatal intensive care. The task needs expertise and experience and is prone to inherent calculation errors. In 1996 we introduced a knowledge-based system called VIE-PNN at the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). It supports the daily calculation of nutrition plans for combined parenteral and enteral nutrition of newborn infants utilizing textbook knowledge and clinical rules of expert neonatologists. VIE-PNN uses a HTML-based client-server architecture and is integrated into the intranet of the local patient data management system (PDMS). The system
Development and evaluation of VIE%2DPNN
Calculating the daily changing composition of parenteral nutrition for small newborn infants is troublesome and time consuming routine work in neonatal intensive care. The task needs expertise and experience and is prone to inherent calculation errors. We designed VIE-PNN, a knowledge-based system in order to reduce daily routine work and calculation errors. VIE-PNN was redesigned several times because the clinicians accepted the system only when it saved time. The most recent version of VIE-PNN uses a HTML-based clientserver architecture and is integrated into the intranet of the local patient data management system. Since more than three years all parenteral nutrition plans are calculated using VIEPNN. Evaluating the system&#039;s performance and the users contentedness, we compared 50 nutrition plans calculated in parallel using VIE-PNN or a hand-held calculator, retrospectively analyzed more than 5000 nutrition plans stored in VIE-PNNs database and evaluated a user questionnaire. Nutrit...
Verification of temporal scheduling constraints in clinical practice guidelines.
The computerization of clinical practice guidelines is a significant scientific challenge for the medical informatics community. One frequently reported factor hindering this objective is the existence of deficiencies within guideline knowledge. In this paper, we focus on the detection of flaws within temporal scheduling constraints. Temporal scheduling constraints are important elements of therapy management, and are frequently incorporated in clinical practice guidelines. We present a suitable verification method that is based on calculating the minimal network of temporal constraints on the execution of guideline activities. Our method serves three purposes: (1) it checks whether temporal scheduling constraints are consistent with scheduling constraints implied by control flow operators and the hierarchical structuring of a guideline; (2) it yields suggestions for an equivalent, yet more explicit representation of non-minimal constraints; (3) it can be used by the guideline interpreter to assemble feasible time intervals for the execution of each guideline activity. We evaluate our approach by applying it to a guideline specified in the Asbru language. For this purpose, we implemented a prototype verifier. Although we concentrate on the guideline representation language Asbru as the demonstration medium of our method within this paper, our approach can be reused to verify several alternative guideline-representation formats.
Visualization methods for data analysis and planning in medical applications.
www.elsevier.com/locate/ijmedinf Visualization methods for data analysis and planning in medical applications
Combining diagnosis and treatment using ASBRU.
Traditionally, diagnosis and treatment have been seen as two distinct tasks. Consequently, most approaches to computer supported health care focus on one of the two -- mostly on diagnosis or rather on the interpretation of measurements which is much better understood and formalized. However, in practice diagnosis and treatment overlap and influence each other in many ways. Combinations range from repeatedly going through the diagnosis-treatment loop over a period of time to permanent monitoring of the patients&#039; health condition as it is done in intensive care units.
Focus and Context Taken Literally.
Pointing out relevant information to a user is one application of focus and context techniques in information visualization. We present a method for doing this which uses selective blur to direct the user&#039;s attention. This method is based on the depth of field effect used in photography and cinematography, and is therefore both familiar to users and perceptually effective. Because this method blurs objects based on their relevance rather than their distance, we call it Semantic Depth of Field (SDOF).
A User Interface for Executing Asbru Plans.

Using Time%2DOriented Data Abstraction Methods to Optimize Oxygen Supply for Neonates.
Therapy management needs sophisticated patient monitoring  and therapy planning, especially in high-frequency domains, like  Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICUs), where complex data sets are  collected every second. An elegant method to tackle this problem is the  use of time-oriented, skeletal plans. Asgaard is a framework for the representation,  visualization, and execution of such plans. These plans work  on qualitative abstracted time-oriented data which closely resemble the  concepts used by experienced clinicians.  This papers presents the data abstraction unit of the Asgaard system.  It provides a range of connectable data abstraction methods bridging  the gap between the raw data collected by monitoring devices and the  abstract concepts used in therapeutic plans. The usability of this data  abstraction unit is demonstrated by the implementation of a controller  for the automated optimization of the fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO2 ).  The use of the time-oriented data abstraction methods results in safe and  smooth adjustment actions of our controller in a neonatal care setting.  1 
Using Critiquing for Improving Medical Protocols Harder than It Seems.
. Medical protocols are widely recognised to provide clinicians with  high-quality and up-to-date recommendations. A critical condition for this is of  course that the protocols themselves are of high quality. In this paper we investigate  the use of critiquing for improving the quality of medical protocols. We constructed  a detailed formal model of the jaundice protocol of the American Association  of Pediatrics in the Asbru representation language. We recorded the actions  performed by a pediatrician while solving a set of test cases. We then compared  these expert actions with the steps recommended by the formalised protocol, and  analysed the differences that we observed. Even our relatively small test set of  7 cases revealed many mismatches between the actions performed by the expert  and the protocol recommendations, which suggest improvements of the protocol.  A major problem in our case study was to establish a mapping between the actions  performed by the expert and the steps suggested by the protocol. We discuss  the reasons for this difficulty, and assess its consequences for the automation of  the critiquing process.  1 
Semantic Depth of Field.
We present a new technique called Semantic Depth of Field (SDOF) as an alternative approach to focus-andcontext displays of information. We utilize a well-known method from photography and cinematography (depth-offield effect) for information visualization, which is to blur different parts of the depicted scene in dependence of their relevance. Independent of their spatial locations, objects of interest are depicted sharply in SDOF, whereas the context of the visualization is blurred. In this paper, we present a flexible model of SDOF which can be easily adopted to various types of applications. We discuss pros and cons of the new technique, give examples of application, and describe a fast prototype implementation of SDOF.
Knowledge%2Dbased verification of clinical guidelines by detection of anomalies.
Within the last decade, clinical guidelines have gained more and more importance in the medical domain, as they provide an efficient means to standardize health care. As a result, the medical community has recently been confronted with numerous approaches, aiming at the automated management of clinical guidelines [e.g. Musen et al., 1996; Ohno-Machado et al., 1997]. Despite the general eagerness in this field, one aspect has been widely neglected by now: Most approaches are lacking mechanisms, which allow for the assurance of a high level of quality for their products. This situation is undesirable insofar, as reliability and quality are critical factors for the successful use of guidelines in real-world applications. In the domain of Software Engineering in general and in the domain of Knowledge-Based Systems in particular, a common strategy to enhance the quality of a system consists in its verification. Therefore, one way out of an imminent quality-crisis in the domain of clinical guidelines is the provision of an effective verification mechanism, appropriate for the analysis of clinical guidelines. Objectives The focus of our work is to develop an approach, which helps to contribute to the
Metaphors of movement a visualization and user interface for time%2Doriented
Therapy planning plays an increasingly important role in the everyday work of physicians. Clinical protocols
Continual Planning with Time%2DOriented%2C Skeletal Plans.
.  In dynamically changing environments a planning system does not have all the required information at the first place and the world state can change, rendering the original plan invalid. Consequently, taking planning to complex, real-world domains calls for close coupling of planning and plan execution, known as continual planning.  In domains where a high degree of adaptability is crucial and little a priori knowledge is available, explorative approaches are suitable. In other domains where comprehensive knowledge is available and human life depends on plan execution, like in medical treatment planning, only approved and validated procedures are admitted. Even more, these procedures constitute a rich asset in the planning task. To combine the utilization of such knowledge with the flexibility necessary in real-world applications, the Asgaard system integrates timeoriented, skeletal planning with real-time monitoring. It features a monolithic framework for the creation, verification,...
A Visualization of Medical Therapy Plans Compared to Gantt and PERT Charts.

Knowledge%2Dbased information management in intensive care and anesthesia.

Abstracting Steady Qualitative Descriptions over Time from Noisy
  On-line monitoring at neonatal intensive care units produces  high volumes of data. Numerous devices generate data at high frequency  (one data set every second). Both, the high volume and the quite high  error-rate of the data make it essential to reach at higher levels of description  from suchraw data. These abstractions should improve the medical  decision making. We will present a time-oriented data-abstraction  method to derive steady qualitative descriptions from ...
Visualization Techniques for Time%2DOriented
. In order to utilize elaborate tools and techniques (like veri-  cation) for use with clinical protocols, these must be represented in an  appropriate way. Protocols are typically represented by means of formal  languages (e.g., Asbru), which are very hard to understand for medical  experts and lead to many problems in practical use. Therefore, a powerful  user interface is needed. We identify the key problems the user-interface  designer is faced with, and present a number of \classic&#034; solutions and  their shortcomings | which led to our own solution called AsbruView.  Its two dierent views (Topological View and Temporal View) are presented.  1 Introduction and Motivation  Clinical protocols exist for many areas of medical care. Such protocols are typically represented as text, tables, or ow-charts. These representations are far from perfect, however, because they lack a clear concept of time and do not allow automation support for verication or quality assessment. In the Asgaard...
Communicating Time%2DOriented%2C Skeletal Plans to Domain Experts Lucidly.
Practical planning systems for real-world environments imply a striking challenge, because the planning and visualization techniques available are not that straightforwardly applicable. Skeletal plans are an effective way to reuse existing domain-specific procedural knowledge, but leave room for execution-time exibility. However, the basic concepts of skeletal plans are not sufficient in our medical domain. First, the temporal dimensions and variability of plans have to be modelled explicitly. Second, the compositions and the interdependencies of different plans are not lucid to medical domain experts. The aim of our paper is to overcome these limitations and to present an intuitive user interface to the plan-representation language Asbru. We explored different representations and developed a powerful plan visualization, called AsbruView. AsbruView consists of two views, first, a topological view, which utilizes the metaphor graphics of &#034;running tracks&#034; and &#034;traffic&#034; and, second, ...
Plan Management in the Medical Domain.
this paper, we adopt Newell&#039;s perspective [51] of a &#034;knowledge level&#034;&#039; analysis rather than addressing this topic at the &#034;symbol level&#034;. Practical plan management requires a &#034;knowledge rich&#034; model [69] that facilitates efficient reasoning given the demands of the surrounding environment. According to our medical interest, approaches dealing with time handling, context, and incomplete information about the world&#039;s states and the effects of actions (dynamically changing environments) are most important.
AsbruView Visualization of Time%2DOriented%2C Skeletal Plans.
Skeletal plans are a powerful way to reuse existing domain-specific  procedural knowledge. The main drawbacks are that  the compositions and the interdependencies of different  skeletal plans and their components are not lucid. The aim of  this paper is to overcome these limitations and to present the  visualization of time-oriented, skeletal plans. Within the  Asgaard project, we have developed a time-oriented and  intention-based language, called Asbru, to represent such  skeletal plans. The Asbru syntax is defined in Backus-Naur  form (BNF). Reading BNF or similar forms are next to impossible  even for domain experts. We explored different  representations and automated knowledge-acquisition tools.  However, the domain experts did not accept any of these  representations. Consequently, we investigated different  metaphor graphics and ended up with a plan visualization  utilizing the metaphors of &#034;tracks&#034; and &#034;traffic&#034;, called  AsbruView. We formatively evaluated different approaches ...
The Asgaard project a task%2Dspecific framework for the application and critiquing of time%2Doriented clinical guidelines.
Clinical guidelines can be viewed as generic skeletal-plan schemata that represent clinical procedural knowledge and that are instantiated and refined dynamically by care providers over significant time periods. In the Asgaard project, we are investigating a set of tasks that support the application of clinical guidelines by a care provider other than the guideline&#039;s designer. We are focusing on application of the guideline, recognition of care providers&#039; intentions from their actions, and critique of care providers&#039; actions given the guideline and the patient&#039;s medical record. We are developing methods that perform these tasks in multiple clinical domains, given an instance of a properly represented clinical guideline and an electronic medical patient record. In this paper, we point out the precise domain-specific knowledge required by each method, such as the explicit intentions of the guideline designer (represented as temporal patterns to be achieved or avoided). We present a machine-readable language, called Asbru, to represent and to annotate guidelines based on the task-specific ontology. We also introduce an automated tool for acquisition of clinical guidelines based on the same ontology, developed using the PROTEGE-II framework.

Quicker%2C More Accurate Nutrition Plans for Newborn Infants.


An Intelligent Assistant for Patient Health Care.
The Patient Advocate is designed to be an intelligent assistant for patient-centered health care. Residing on a home computer or special-purpose device and operating within an extended health-care information network, the Patient Advocate will extend medical expertise into the outpatient setting. It will have remote access to the patient’s medical record, an understanding of the patient’s health status and history, and a model of the patient’s interest in health-related issues, preferences for modes and contents of interaction, etc. The Patient Advocate is being designed to provide three kinds of functions. First, it will assist the patient in managing continuing ambulatory conditions, for example chronic problems such as diabetes, special normal conditions such as prenatal care, and wellness issues such as diet, exercise, and stress. Second, it will provide health-related information by allowing the patient to interact with the online health-care information network and scan media resources to suggest information of interest. Third, it will act as a remote triage point for clinical services by coordinating patient-relevant information such as reminding the patient when a visit to the clinic is indicated. We describe a prototype of the Patient Advocate which is designed to support obstetrics patients at risk of gestational diabetes. It is important that the Patient Advocate is platform-independent, runs on widely available hosts, and has access to various Internet resources. Therefore, it is implemented in Java and is Internet accessible. 1. Patient-Centered Care is Needed In recent years, several knowledge-based systems have been introduced to support health care providers (mainly clinicians) with the monitoring of critical care patients and to assist them with diagnostic decisions and therapy planning (Uckun 1994b). These systems range from simple intelligent alarms to sophisticated systems for anesthesia monitoring or ventilator management (e.g.,
Time%2DOriented Skeletal Plans Support to Design and Execution.
$EVWUDFW Skeletal plans are a powerful way to reuse existing domain-specific procedural knowledge. In the $VJDDUG project, a set of tasks that support the design and the execution of skeletal plans by a human executing agent other than the original plan designer are designed. The underlying requirement to develop task-specific problem-solving methods is a PRGHOLQJ ODQJXDJe. Therefore, within the Asgaard project, a time-oriented, intention-based language, called $VEUX, was developed. During the design phase of plans, Asbru allows to express durative actions and plans caused by durative states of an observed agent. The intentions underlying these plans are represented explicitly as temporal patterns to be maintained, achieved or avoided. We will present the underlying idea of the Asgaard project and explain the time-oriented Asbru language. Finally, we show the benefits and limitations of the time-oriented, skeletal plan representation to be applicable in real-world, high-frequency domains. 0RWLYDWLRQ DQG,QWURGXFWLRQ We are motivated by the need for knowledge-based support in the medical

Medizinische Leitlinien und Protokolle das Asgaard%2FAsbru%2DProjekt.


Therapy Planning Using Qualtitative Trend Descriptions.

Context%2DSensitive Data Validation and Data Abstraction for Knowledge%2DBased Monitoring.
ion for Knowledge--Based Monitoring  Silvia Miksch!, Werner Horn!  @,  Christian Popow#, Franz Paky$ !  Austrian Research Institute for Artificial Intelligence (\FAI) Schottengasse 3, A--1010 Vienna, Austria email: silvia@ai.univie.ac.at @  Department of Medical Cybernetics and Artificial Intelligence, University of Vienna Freyung 6/2, A--1010 Vienna, Austria #  Department of Pediatrics, NICU, University of Vienna W{hringer G}rtel 18--20, A--1090 Vienna, Austria $  Department of Pediatrics, Hospital of M|dling Weyprechtgasse 12, A--2340 M|dling, Austria Abstract  This paper addresses two important components of our knowledge--based system, VIE--VENT, a monitoring and therapy planning system for artificially ventilated newborn infants: data validation and data abstraction. VIE--VENT is specifically designed for practical use under real--time constraints in Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICUs). Monitoring includes observing and guiding the behavior of a system. We concentrate on the ini...
